Peer Review Process

Initial Editorial Assessment

Every manuscript submitted to Jurnal Rekayasa Lingkungan dan Keberlanjutan (JRLK) undergoes an initial assessment by the editorial team. At this stage, the manuscript is evaluated for its relevance to the journal’s focus and scope, originality, scientific quality, methodological soundness, compliance with the author guidelines, research ethics, and overall suitability for peer review.

The manuscript may also be screened using recognised similarity-detection software, such as iThenticate, Turnitin, or another appropriate plagiarism-detection system. Submissions that fall outside the journal’s scope, contain serious methodological weaknesses, fail to meet the journal’s requirements, or demonstrate unacceptable levels of similarity may be rejected without external review.

Double-Anonymised Peer Review

Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial assessment will be evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. JRLK applies a double-anonymised peer-review process, in which the identities of both the authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.

Reviewers assess each manuscript based on its originality, scientific contribution, methodological rigour, accuracy of analysis, clarity of presentation, relevance to environmental engineering and sustainability, adequacy of references, ethical compliance, and significance for academic or professional practice.

Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based comments. They must maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and disclose any potential conflict of interest that could affect the impartiality of their evaluation.

Revision and Author Response

Reviewers’ comments and recommendations will be communicated to the corresponding author through the journal’s online submission system. When revisions are requested, the author must submit a revised manuscript together with a detailed response explaining how each comment has been addressed. Any recommendation that is not followed should be accompanied by a clear and academically justified explanation.

Depending on the extent of the revisions, the revised manuscript may be reassessed by the editor or returned to the original reviewers for an additional round of evaluation. More than one revision round may be required before a final decision is reached.

Editorial Decision

Reviewer recommendations serve as an important basis for editorial consideration; however, the final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or the responsible editor. The decision is made by considering the reviewers’ reports, the authors’ responses, the scientific quality of the revised manuscript, ethical requirements, and its relevance to the journal.

Editors must not participate in the assessment of manuscripts in which they have personal, professional, institutional, or financial conflicts of interest. Such submissions will be assigned to another qualified editor to ensure an independent and impartial decision-making process.

Review Outcomes

Based on the peer-review reports and editorial assessment, one of the following decisions will be issued:

  • Reject: The manuscript is unsuitable for publication because of substantial concerns regarding its scope, originality, scientific quality, methodology, ethical compliance, or overall contribution. A rejected manuscript may not be resubmitted in the same form.
  • Resubmit for Review: The manuscript requires substantial redevelopment before it can be considered further. Authors may submit a thoroughly revised version, which will be treated as a new review round and may be evaluated again by independent reviewers.
  • Major Revisions Required: The manuscript has publication potential but requires significant changes to its methodology, analysis, interpretation, structure, or presentation. The revised manuscript will normally undergo another round of peer review.
  • Minor Revisions Required: The manuscript is scientifically acceptable but requires limited corrections or clarifications. The revised manuscript may be evaluated directly by the responsible editor or returned to the reviewers when necessary.
  • Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication. It will proceed to copyediting, layout, proofreading, and production, subject to the completion of all required publication documents.

Estimated Review Period

JRLK aims to complete the peer-review and initial decision process within a maximum of approximately 8 weeks from the date the manuscript passes the initial editorial assessment. The actual processing time may vary depending on reviewer availability, the complexity of the manuscript, the number of revision rounds, and the responsiveness of the authors.

The journal is committed to conducting a fair, confidential, transparent, and rigorous peer-review process. Acceptance decisions are based exclusively on academic merit and are not influenced by the authors’ institutional affiliation, nationality, gender, personal background, or payment of the Article Processing Charge.