Article Review Guide
Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts objectively, confidentially, and constructively based on the journal’s scope and publication ethics.
The review should focus on the relevance and originality of the topic, clarity of objectives, appropriateness of the community service method, adequacy of data and evidence, significance of results and community impact, quality of discussion, appropriateness of conclusions, quality and currency of references, language clarity, and overall contribution to environmental engineering and sustainability.
Reviewers should also identify any potential ethical concerns, plagiarism, duplicate publication, unsupported claims, or conflicts of interest. Comments should be clear, specific, respectful, and helpful to the authors.
Based on the overall quality of the manuscript, reviewers may recommend Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.